top of page

Songs We Loved In High School: Two New Playlists

The spring season of the Local Show wrapped up last week with a very special edition: Songs We Loved in High School, as performed by Andrew Peterson, Andrew Osenga, Andy Gullahorn, Jill Phillips, Eric Peters, and Sandra McCracken. There were songs by the Indigo Girls, Marc Cohn, Crowded House, R. E. M., James Taylor, DC Talk, and so much more—more than you could have ever hoped for.

Today, we share with you the complete set list from that glorious night. And, as long as we’re having fun, we’re sharing a second playlist representing some of our contributors’ favorite songs from high school as well. Suffice it to say that we’ve been greatly enjoying our walk down memory lane.

“In this season’s final edition of the Local Show, we had some longtime Rabbit Room favorites share covers of songs they loved in high school. Affectionately known as the ‘Square Pegs,’ they included Andrew Peterson, Sandra McCracken, Eric Peters, Andrew Osenga, Jill Phillips, and Andy Gullahorn. It was an incredibly fun night with everybody from Bruce Hornsby and the Indigo Girls to Marc Cohn and DC Talk. Sadly, the livestream wasn’t working, but if you get the chance, check out @thelocalshow on Instagram for some clips of the show.”

—Jared Malament

Set List

Jill Phillips: “Stay (I Missed You)” by Lisa Loeb Andy Gullahorn: “Everything That Glitters” by Dan Seals Eric Peters: “Look Out Any Window” by Bruce Hornsby Andrew Osenga: “It’s the End of the World As We Know It” (And I Feel Fine) by R.E.M. Andrew Peterson: “Walking in Memphis” by Marc Cohn Andrew Peterson: “Silver Thunderbird” by Marc Cohn Sandra McCracken: “Closer to Fine” by Indigo Girls Group: “Carolina in My Mind” by James Taylor

Andy Gullahorn/Jill Phillips, et al: “High Enough” by Damn Yankees Eric Peters: “These Days” by Jackson Browne Andrew Osenga: “Jesus Freak” by DC Talk Jill Phillips: “Summer Solstice” by Susan Ashton Andrew Peterson: “Heart of the Matter” by Don Henley Sandra McCracken: “The Gambler” by Kenny Rogers Andy Gullahorn: “The Living Years” by Mike + The Mechanics Andrew Osenga: “Wonderwall” by Oasis Jill Phillips: “Don’t Dream It’s Over” by Neil Finn/Crowded House

You can listen to the full Local Show set list on Spotify and Apple Music.

Our Songs We Loved From High School playlist is also available to stream on Spotify and Apple Music.


bottom of page